I have kind of a love/hate relationship with James Dashner (his website is drop-dead gorgeous so you should check it out if for no other reason than to enjoy the eye candy). I loved his Maze Runner series, but was disappointed in the prequel. I was likewise underwhelmed by the 13th Reality. So I've been putting off starting Eye of Minds, but with an unspent Audible credit hanging around, I thought I'd give it a try.
Ready Player One... actually it's almost exactly like Ready Player One so far as tech and setting, so I've got to ding Dashner's creativity there. I do appreciate that he's delivered a similar world without the sex and language of Ready Player One for younger readers to enjoy. I just wish he could have been a little more cleaver with it.
For those who haven't read either book, allow me to explain: The Internet has become a Matrix-like virtual world. To access said world people climb into computerized coffins that allowing them to feel and experience everything as if it were real. Many people spend more time in the VertNet than in the waking world. Why one would want to experience the tedium of having to walk to the Google website to send some mail, then to Amazon to pick out some books and then across the web to Destiny for a few rounds of alien blasting makes no sense to me, but I digress.
The outside world is a bit messed up, so the hero, Michael, spends a lot of time in the VertNet. The book opens with Dashner's signature shock moment (which is very attention grabbing) and takes off on a whirl wind adventure to uncover who the evil gamer Kane really is and what his nifarous agenda is for the VertNet. Throw in some sidekicks, crazy killer programs, a Pilgrim's Progress-style unravel-the-mystery journey and you've got yourself an interesting read.
Please, note: interesting. Not: good.
The book has a few substantial flaws that drift it away from good and towards the "meh" spectrum of books.
First, as mentioned, the unoriginal world building.
Second there are some funny tech moments that show an ignorance of tech or, at the very least, a lack of creativity on behalf of the author. The characters use keyboards to participate in several IM-style conversations which I must call BS on. I can talk to my PlayStation for goodness sake, I can operate my computer by touch. The idea that, in a world where VR is REAL, they're still banging away on QWERTY keyboards is laughable. Also, we're constantly made aware that since Michael and his friends have the very best VR coffins they'll experience every horrific moment of pain of what's inflicted on them in the game world. I find this painfully silly. I can adjust dozens of settings on my TV for goodness sake, and you're telling me you can't adjust pain settings in a VR coffin? That's just bad design right there, like finding a new car without seats that can be tilted or moved forward or back.
Third, there are quite a few lengthy passages where Dashner feels the need to describe everything a character does in a day. He went to school. Came home. Made himself lunch, ham and cheese on rye, pickles and a glass of milk... etc. I'm not kidding. That's how it goes. Fortunately my Kindle does have a pain adjustment setting and I skipped some of those passages.
Finally, the characters are just a little inconsistent and flat. His friends are your basic Ron and Hermione knock offs. He's silly. She's smart etc. but the hero never really needs either of them except to discuss things that have just happened or are going to happen. They are amazing hackers but don't think of even the simplest hacks to help themselves out of trouble. I never got around to caring about any of them or what was happening. Maybe partly because at the back of my mind I always knew they were just in a virtual world and thus, completely safe. The threat of not being able to get back into a game just wasn't high enough stakes for me.
The book does end with a fantastic and (again) signature Dashner twist I didn't see coming that made the last chapters fly past but unfortunately by that point it was too little too late for me.
What to know: Like all Dashner books there is a smattering of language, and a generous helping of gore and bloody violence. There are also kids in peril (sort of) but nothing that would scare away anyone but the most sensitive of readers.
So, if you've always wanted to read Ready Player One but didn't want the
"adult" part of the content or if you have a spare Audible credit going
to waste, give Eye of Minds a read. I'd be willing to read the second
book to see where Dashner takes the plot, and to see if he can juice up
the originality now that his world's in place.
And that, I guess, is my two cents.
Liked this? Writers live and die on word of mouth so please share
or follow or join my mailing list. See the top right of this page.